In the second critique, kant criticizes the stoics for straining the moral capacities of a. Find materials for this course in the pages linked along the left. Famine, affluence, and morality peter singer kantian approaches to some famine problems onora oneill the survival lottery john harris active and passive euthanasia james rachels a reply to rachels on active and passive euthanasia a defense of abortion judith jarvis thompson an argument that abortion is. Kantianism and utilitarianism have different ways for determining whether an act we do is right or wrong. March 5 and 7, discussing onora oneills article kantian approaches to some famine problems. Groundwork for the metaphysics of morals onora oneill. Type chapter authors onora oneill date 20 page start 510 page end 520 ebook. Justice requires that we act on no maxims that use others as mere means. Kant, groundwork of the metaphysics of morals wednesday, may 20. Pdf kants absolute good will and its implications for some. Suffering and death from lack of food, shelter and medical care are bad. Instead of giving a utilitarian account, which focuses strictly on the consequences of ones actions, she gives a kantian, dutybased account, which. Oneill, o 1980 kantian approaches to some famine problems. Pdf oneill kantian approaches to some famine problems.
Kantian approaches to some famine problems online simplified summary oneills approach to the question of what affluent people ought to do for those suffering from famine differs substantially from peter singers. Philosophy seminar online readings hanover college. Oct 17, 2018 quite understandably, one may wonder whether kants virtue ethics approach has to tell us something about famine relief, poverty and disasters on a global stage. Some problems amrita rangasami the study of famine in the different disciplines appear to offer the famine is an extreme event, marked by disease and mortality eco famine is a period of psychosocial breakdown. According to kant, we should look at our maxims, or intentions, of the particular action. Preface to the third edition preface to the first edition introduction. Code onora oneill 1941 kantian approaches to some famine problems onora oneill is a professor of philosophy at the university of essex. Kant s formula of universal law 499 christine korsgaard 57. Such a theory, she argues, provides a better normative response to hunger and famine than utilitarianism and human rights approaches. An anthology features a comprehensive collection of more than 80 essays from classic and contemporary philosophers that address questions at the heart of moral philosophy. The main objection we considered to egoism was that it failed to accommodate the common sense idea that morality involves a kind of impartiality, at the very least it seems that. In kants view, acts done on maxims that endanger, coerce, or deceive others, and thus cannot in. There is then quite a sharp distinction between the requirements of justice and of beneficence in kantian ethics. In sharp contrast to peter singer, onora oneill approaches the problem of world hunger from a kantian perspective.
According to certain kantian scholars, these two duties constitute the core of kantian ethics oneill 1993. Her works include acting on principle and faces of hunger. Kantian obligation never to act in ways in which others cannot in principle also act. Kantian approaches to some famine problems 686 john harris. Classics of epistemology meditations on first philosophy, rene descartes some further considerations.
Recommended but not required, david velleman, a brief introduction to kantian ethics april 20. View theories of famine research papers on academia. Start studying oneill kantian approaches to some famine problems. Oneill, kantian approaches to some famine problems. Evaluation of possible solutions to world hunger science. T 65 kant, groundwork of the metaphysics of morals selections deontology w 66 oneill, kantian approaches to some famine problems. Quite understandably, one may wonder whether kant s virtue ethics approach has to tell us something about famine relief, poverty and disasters on a global stage. Rightclick and select save target as or save link as. Click the button below to open the forum page in a new window.
Peter singer, famine, affluence, and morality immanuel kant, groundwork of the metaphysic of morals david velleman, a brief introduction to kantian ethics onora oneill, kantian approaches to some famine problems. Kantian and utilitarian viewpoints on famine relief immanuel kant proposed the kantian theory. Google scholar, then a kantian ethic does require one to pursue the happiness of others, albeit in that very specific sense differing from the one relevant to african ethics. Kantian and utilitarian viewpoints on famine relief 1100. Nutrition sciences, famine is a sudden collapse, distinct from poverty economics. Oneill applies kantian ethical theory to the problem of famine relief. Oneill phil pg 538544 onora oneill kantian approaches. The utilitarian approach entails the knowledge and consequences of all possible actions committed or none. The problem of abortion and the doctrine of the double effect 536 philippa foot. Pdf to be beneficent, that is, to promote according to ones means the. Pathway in philosophy oup, 2004 pp265317 roger scruton. Philosophy and the meaning of life the value of philosophy, bertrand russell the province of philosophy, j. Korsgaard, kant s formulation of universal law introduction and 57. There is also a massive and comprehensive scope application to the problem.
A simplified account of kants ethics 4 justice requires that we act on no maxims that use others as mere means. Immanuel kant 17241804 immanuel kant was born on april 22, 1724 in konigsberg, east prussia. Oneills a simplified account of kantian ethics ph115. The rationality of side constraints 521 robert nozick. Groundwork of the metaphysics of morals 485 immanuel kant 56. Sally haslanger december 2, 2001 kantian ethics and more on famine so far weve looked at egoist and utilitarian approaches to ethics. It is currently published as a searchable online platform with profiles of world problems, action strategies, and human values that are interlinked in novel and innovative ways. Rights, obligations and world hunger first published in poverty and social justice. Disaster utilitarianism deontology kant virtue duty autonomy end justice beneficence.
Onora oneill, kantian approaches to some famine problems c. Utilitarianism, groundwork to the metaphysics of morals. Onora oneill, kantian approaches to some famine problems download. Oneill phil pg 538544 onora oneill kantian approaches to. Essays utilitarian famine one of the monolithic problems confronting the world today is famine.
At age 8, he entered the collegium fredericianum, a latin school, where he remained for 8 12 years and studied the classics. Famine reliefmoral problems and the good life coursephilosophy. Oneill, kantian approaches to some famine problems assignment. Kantian approaches to some famine problems september 14 john rawls. Onora oneill 1980 kantian approaches to some famine problems. Groundwork of the metaphysics of morals 485 immanuel kant. Furthermore, even if this is feasible in some cases, it need not imply necessarily that it is the.
He argues that, because this is the only universal moral rule in the same way that the ci is kants only universal moral rule, there is no basis for distinguishing between obligatory moral action e. With the struggle to find and to eat food, people are not free to pursue higher goals or to contemplate justice amongst equals, much less rights. Article information, pdf download for rigorist cosmopolitanism, open epub. The examples kant gives in the metaphysics of morals of perfect.
This work employing the analytic and critical methods exposed the contents of kants moral theory and tested its viability as a moral standard by. The paper discusses whether codes of ethics are kantian notions through an analysis of their intention and structure. This does not seem to me to be an irresponsible approach in this case. Kantian approaches to some famine problems murdoch university. Famine, affluence and morality 466 peter singer 54.
Onora oneill normative application of kantian moral theory. Oxford university press usa publishes scholarly works in all academic disciplines, bibles, music, childrens books, business books, dictionaries, reference books, journals, text books and more. The demandingness of a kantian duty to alleviate global. Major issues in philosophy oneill, a simplified account of kants ethics 4. The ontological argument, saint anselm the existence of god. Oneill, onora 1993 kantian approaches to some famine problems. Onora oneill kantian deliberations on famine problems. There are differences in kantian s famine solutions and the standard utilitarian approach toward famine. The problem of evil dialogues concerning natural religion, david hume god, evil and the best of all possible worlds, gottfried leibniz hume on evil, nelson pike evil and omnipotence, j. Kantian and utilitarian viewpoints on famine relief 1100 words. Peter singer, famine, affluence, and morality april 15. Immanuel kant, groundwork of the metaphysic of morals. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.
Famine reliefmoral problems and the good life course. Though there are many actions that a person can take, they only have a few duties in life. The article also discusses some of the ideas put forward by william starr in his article, codes of ethics towards a ruleutilitarian justification,journal of business ethics 22 may 1983. Even though kant states that it is impossible to assign determinate limits to the extent of the sacrifices agents have to make on the grounds of their duty of beneficence, he nevertheless provides us with some general restrictions that have to be imposed upon the sacrifices the agent has to make. Kantians believe human life is valuable because humans are the bearers of rational life oneill 414. As it has benefited from the work of many scholars, it is not suitable for citation. In this essay, i will summarize kant s attempted derivation, then compare his argument in favor of beneficence with peter singers. Kants ethics one on which i shall concentrate is known as the. Oneill goes on to illustrate the difference between her advocated kantian famine solutions and the standard utilitarian approach, which entails the knowledgeable consequences of all possible actions, that means actions committed and non. It is based on view that the only intrinsically good thing is goodwill. A theory of justice excerpt 4 september 18 robert nozick. Readings moral problems and the good life linguistics. Virtue ethics is the best approach to ethics because it recognizes.
In considering the problem of global justice and, more specifically, famine, singer relies on a broadly consequentialist approach. To download the above lecture material use this link. Kantian ethics groundwork of the metaphysic of morals, chapter 2 pojman, l. Kants formula of universal law 499 christine korsgaard. This page is for all parts of the course up through kant. Onora oneill a simplified account of kant s ethics cahn thurs, feb 16 onora oneill kantian approaches to some famine problems pdf i reserve the right to add to eliminate change the readings assigned in this course. Presentation of onora oneills kantian approaches to some famine problems by phil jenkins for his fall 2017 online ethics class at marywood university. The paper refers to recent definitions of codes of ethics and considers. As a kantian scholar, one of the major criticisms oneill has with singers solution, and utilitarian reasoning in general, is its impractical or infeasible nature. Immanuel kant, groundwork of the metaphysics of morals 52. Jul 22, 20 in famine, affluence, and morality, singer adopts happinesssuffering as his basis of moral value. Discussion forum for discussion on this topic, please go to the relevant forum for moral problems and the good life. The words maxim and intention are used interchangeably when talking about deontology.
Some duties are more important than others, and duties of justice are the duties most valued by kant. The encyclopedia of world problems and human potential is a unique, experimental research work of the union of international associations. Do the other approaches to ethics give us further insight into our obligations to the distant needy. In kant s view, acts done on maxims that endanger, coerce, or deceive others, and thus cannot in. Kantian approaches to some famine problems 510 onora oneill. As such, an action can only be good if its maxim is good. Which formulation of the categorical imperative does oneill apply to some famine problems. Onora oneill, kantian approaches to some famine problems, in reason and responsibility, pp. The main method by which i propose to avoid some of the difficulties of kant s moral theory is by explaining only one part of the theory. Type chapter authors oneill onora is part of book title ethical theory. Selections from oneill, kantian approaches to some famine problems 2 pages selections from frankfurt, coercion and moral responsibility 1. The survival lottery 474 john harris part ix deontology 479 introduction to part ix 481 55.
Onora oneill, kantian approaches to some famine problems. Kantian approaches to some famine problems to act beneficently is to act to help others achieve their own goals willed through their maxims kantian justice forbids us from using others as a means, but we are not required to direct beneficence first to those who need it most. Chapter 57 kantian approaches to some famine problems. That is the approach of kantian theory toward famine. Classical and contemporary readings,sixth edition, is the most comprehensive topically organized collection of classical and contemporary philosophy available. The case for open borders september 28 marilynn frye. Act in such a way that you always treat humanity, whether in your own person or in the person of any other, never simply as a means but always at the same time as an end. Kant s moral theory has acquired the reputation of being forbiddingly difficult to understand and, once understood, excessively demanding in its requirements. In famine, affluence and morality, which first appeared in 1972.
Beneficence requires that we act on some maxims that foster others ends, though it is a matter for judgment and discretion which of their ends we foster. Kantian approaches to some famine problems 510 onora oneill 58. Oneill kantian approaches to some famine problems handout. Act in such a way that you always treat humanity, whether in your own person or in the person of any other, never simply as.
1576 748 1070 962 1003 938 1232 1442 318 98 823 1387 1240 1316 980 756 458 1019 413 1336 673 1295 821 1199 1068 951 1156 1429 935 1433 1158 1117 923 941 989 144 815